Pope Leo XIV steps into the spotlight. Credit: Canva
When Pope Leo XIV stepped into the balcony of St. Peter’s Basilica this year, many were hoping for a gentle continuation of Pope Francis’ legacy. However, within a few weeks it became clear that Leo XIV was not only repositioning the torch, but not simply carrying it. His first gesture is symbolic and unmistakable, rekindling the old tensions at the heart of the Catholic Church. Rather than choosing tradition and transformation, Leo XIV appears to be walking both paths at once, which may be his most fundamental move.
Dressed like Benedict and spoke like Frances
Pope Leo XIV, formerly known as the Cardinal of Robert Prevost, reintroduced the Pope’s symbol, which had been in ruins. Red Mosetta, gorgeous Pope Ferra, and more formal wear are back.
Many conservative Catholics believe this is a recovery for the United States and parts of Europe. After years of people who called “excessive humility” under Francis, Leo’s return to tradition was welcomed as a rebalance. In his first Homily, he chose not to emphasize doctrine, but to emphasize division by stating that Catholics choose love over ideology. The robe he wore may be old, but the tone is modern.
Another type of leadership
Pope Francis is known for his bold speech and often criticised climate change denial, global inequality and political nationalism. His style was direct and confrontational, and Pope Leo XIV sent the standard message in a gentle way. He advocated the need for peace in Ukraine and offered prayers in Gaza. His approach is simple. Do not modify the message.
For years, the Catholic Church has been sandwiched between two groups. He wants to maintain strong traditions, including rituals, rules and doctrines. Others want the church to be more open and modern, especially towards LGBTQ+ people, the environment and social justice. Pope Francis relied on the latter group and focused more on inclusion and reform, but Leo XIV does something different in order to respect both sides without choosing it.
In doing so, he shows the conservatives that their traditions are important and clarifies the church’s mission to care for the poor, excluded, planets. Pope Leo XIV is trying to bring people back to the centre, not division or ally. He dresses in the traditional pope form, but he speaks with kindness, caregiving, cherishing old rituals, and wants the church to remain close to the needs and pain of the world. In an age when everyone felt compelled to be on their side, Pope Leo provides balance by moving forward with open hands rather than standing still.
